Playability: 5
(Every computer player works, and there is enough build space.)
Balance: 4
(Balance is okay but not quite perfect. Try putting in even amounts of iron, stone, and wood.)
Creativity: 4
(It was semi-creative, however, map one didn't have much to it. Map two was pretty creative.)
Map Design: 3
(I'm sorry to say but, neither of these maps were very... beautiful... You did try to mix textures I saw, but the way you did it wasn't so good... Now I'm not trying to discourage you from making maps however all I am saying is that you need to put something a little extra into your map to make it look good. Check out my previous map The Scottish War (part 1) and look at how I textured the ground or check out frankomans new map The Great Siege. They may help a lot.)
Story/Instructions: 5
(None needed, the carnage sufficed.)
Additional Comments: I'm pretty sure that I said everything on the Map Design post. I hope you continue map-making I see potential! By the way I'm sorry that this review got to you so late.