Playability: 5
Its playable and I had alot of fun playing this map! The problem is fixed and so you earn a five!
Balance: 5
They all have very defensible positions and it is hard to get near their keep without suffering heavy losses!
Creativity: 5
Its creative!
Map Design: 4.9
Much better the waterflls and rivers are perfect I spent ages looking at them from all possible angles! The vegatation is better and I am glad you scattered a few rocks around.
The Iron mines are perfect, the marsh is perfect, but you must have misunderstood what I meant with the Quarrys! I said you should scatter some of the
small grey rocks around the Quarry not the big grey rocks in the Quarry! Otherwise I can not spot anything wrong with this map and It does not really matter!
Story/Instructions: 5
It is not bad at all!
I wouldn't mind even if it was bad I don't care about a story in a kingmaker!
Additional Comments:
It is a good map and I would play this many times! I have pointed out a few things you could improve on above but overall this is one of the best youve made and keep it up!
I am a bit overwelmed at the moment so if there are maps I don't cover then I am sorry and Im doing the best I can!
[Edited on 02/27/06 @ 12:19 PM]
Sir Piepod
Posted on 04/08/09 @ 06:21 PM
Rating
4.7
Breakdown
Playability
5.0
Balance
4.0
Creativity
5.0
Map Design
4.5
Story/Instructions
5.0
Playability: 5
Amazing, no glitches or anything. Truly a stunning map.
Balance: 4
Well, overall it was pretty balanced, although you say it isn't. All estates had a pretty equally good position, except the one in the very bottom right. I don't like that one, the hills to the north of it "cloak" the enemy and its hard to build walls there. The stones there too and its hard to protect your stone miners :S
Creativity: 5
Very creative in the landscape: looks natural and beautiful.
Map Design: 4.5
Good strategic designs of the estates.
Story/Instructions: 5
Well you made instructions very clear about what to expect and watch out for.
Additional Comments:
GREAT MAP!!!
klaxxor
Posted on 07/17/10 @ 02:23 AM
Rating
5.0
Breakdown
Playability
5.0
Balance
5.0
Creativity
5.0
Map Design
5.0
Story/Instructions
5.0
Playability: 5
No glitches!
Balance: 5
Lots of variation while still being balanced, well done!
Creativity: 5
Every detail is well thought-out, creating a realistic little world!
Map Design: 5
Plenty of territories to fight over between the castles.