Best of Stronghold 2
This page contains all maps that are rated 4.0 and higher, based on two or more reviews.
Out of a total of 1038 downloads 482 have been rated with 125 making it in to the list. A total of 896 comments/ratings have been submitted, 421 of which are represented in these results. These have been submitted by 71 out of a total of 382 authors, 230 of whom are rated.
A total of 5019 comments were given, 896 included ratings. These comments were given by 617 different people, 240 who were kind enough to give ratings.
As you see can the list is rather short on data, so do us and our other visitors a favour and please rate any scenario you play, even if you didn't like it.
Best of Stronghold 2
| Rating | Map | Author | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5.0 (5) | Custom Female Type Crest | ladytrina | Miscellaneous Files |
| 5.0 (4) | Valley Ruins | Doomsword | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 5.0 (2) | El Cid | Gordon Farrell | War Scenarios |
| 5.0 (2) | Stronghold 2 AI Editor | Britian | Utility Programs |
| 5.0 (2) | The Lamb | Robert Euvino | Miscellaneous Files |
| 5.0 (5) | Mystic Valley | Accolon | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.9 (3) | Aedile Ordeal 1.4 | aedile | War Scenarios |
| 4.9 (3) | Obsidion | Lord cliff | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.9 (5) | The day the earth spit fire... | Stratego | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.9 (6) | The Deep Valley | Lord Eyre | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.9 (4) | The Viking War (part I) | SirWhiteWolf | War Scenarios |
| 4.9 (2) | Golden Valley by WarLord Designs | WarLord_Designs | Freebuild Scenarios |
| 4.9 (2) | Over Hill and Valley | Lord Eyre | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.9 (2) | Ring Of Brodgar Episode 3 "Kindred Souls" | Sir MichaelP | War Scenarios |
| 4.9 (2) | The Scottish War (Part II) | SirWhiteWolf | War Scenarios |
| 4.9 (2) | Valley Waterfall | DJeckman | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (9) | Riverpath | Lord Eyre | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (3) | Load Screens - Minas Tirith | Redmoon | Miscellaneous Files |
| 4.8 (6) | Eternity Garden | kazpa | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (5) | Green Hills and Fields | Gilzenaarkas | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (4) | The Scottish War (Part III) | SirWhiteWolf | War Scenarios |
| 4.8 (3) | Waterfall Plaza | HorseArcher06 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (2) | Great Lakes Gathering | Shadrac | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (2) | Odin's Footprint | Stratego | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.8 (2) | SETTLERS OF CATAN | Accolon | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (2) | Siege of Olaf | Clubthumper | War Scenarios |
| 4.8 (2) | The Doge of Venice | Harleybulli | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.8 (3) | Raid on Ragnar's Fjord | Stratego | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.8 (5) | Craggy Island | brave sir robyn | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.7 (3) | Ring of Brodgar - Knights of Ahearn | Sir MichaelP | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (3) | The Grey Monk | HorseArcher06 | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (10) | Deadman's Pass: Episode 6 | turtleman387 | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (7) | Colosseum V1.2 (2 versions) | Gilzenaarkas | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (4) | Vulture's Canyon: Episode 7 | turtleman387 | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (2) | Death Canyon | Big Ben | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (2) | Forage & Fertility | elboldizar | Freebuild Scenarios |
| 4.7 (2) | Island Madness | jmssup16 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (2) | Marshy Mayhem (based on the original) | mangoman | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (7) | LoTR Mini Release Pack | Britian | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (8) | Stamford Bridge | Gordon Farrell | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (3) | Cliffs of Insanity | gattaca2420 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (3) | Ghosttown | Accolon | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (3) | King of the Hill | Yellek | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (3) | RUIN ISLAND | Accolon | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (8) | Wicked Coast of Cornwall | Clarinetcat | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (4) | Cat’s T.T.T.T (Teeny Tiny Training Town) | Clarinetcat | War Scenarios |
| 4.7 (4) | Morganshire | RounderOH | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.7 (4) | Tintagel | Accolon | War Scenarios |
| 4.6 (3) | Clawed Cliff Cape by X29 | X29 | War Scenarios |
| 4.6 (3) | Hell and Heaven | Harleybulli | War Scenarios |
| 4.6 (2) | The Ring of 13 Stones | drkusa | Freebuild Scenarios |
| 4.6 (6) | PILGRAMAGE IS NOT PARADISE | Harleybulli | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (2) | The Journey | Sir_Vet | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | A River Runs Through It | RedRanger3 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | Barbarian Attack | frankoman | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | Forest Maze | gattaca2420 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | The Pass | Bouncer315 | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | The Supply Effect | ReggieREAL | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (6) | Kill Dragon | DJeckman | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (5) | Cumbria, The Heart of Olaf | Clarinetcat | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (5) | Marooned! | Stratego | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | The Scottish War (Part.1) | SirWhiteWolf | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (2) | Arthur's Invasion | Sir Leo | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (2) | Kingdom Of Mansoned | Sir_Mike III | Freebuild Scenarios |
| 4.5 (2) | Wrath of a Bully | Accolon | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | Darkwood Castle | Gilzenaarkas | War Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | Niaggairus Falls | RedRanger3 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.5 (3) | Quiglesbury Castle | brave sir robyn | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (5) | The War on Efewme | Efewme888 | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (4) | RUIN ISLAND | Accolon | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (4) | Seven Dragons | Gilzenaarkas | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.4 (4) | The New World | fokkedup | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (3) | In A Big Country - Mission 2: The Taint v1.01 | pad11 | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (3) | Port Orchard | bitspec | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.4 (3) | Ring Of Brodgar - Island of the crescent moon | Sir MichaelP | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (3) | Upper Estates | Sir_Vet | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.4 (2) | Castle Landunder | Lord cliff | War Scenarios |
| 4.4 (2) | Cottonmouth | bitspec | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.4 (2) | Hill War by Gilzenaarkas | Gilzenaarkas | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.4 (2) | Snowdonia | Wulfwyn Wessex | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | Turtle Rock | turtleman387 | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | Viva la France | Accolon | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | Dunham County | HorseArcher06 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | White Cliffs of Dover | Clarinetcat | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (4) | Rescue Lady Seren from the Bull's prison | kevn357 | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.3 (4) | The Fall of the Knights Templar | frankoman | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (2) | 4 player kingmaker map with detailed landscape and various eyecandys | stevo templar | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.3 (2) | Final Sacrifice (Part I: Trials of The Lord) | Clarinetcat | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (2) | Hadrians Wall | wisewoody | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.3 (2) | Realm of the Elves | turtleman387 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.3 (2) | runes of the earth | cutestuff | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.3 (2) | The escape of Moses | Lopat | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (6) | Brothers | lastnametherewas | War Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | Malchaos: Planet of War | turtleman387 | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | Shovoria | Sh0v0r | Peace Scenarios |
| 4.3 (3) | Assault on the Great Wall | fokkedup | War Scenarios |
| 4.2 (4) | Middleton | SlubbertyGullit | Kingmaker Scenarios |
| 4.2 (4) | LOST | Harleybulli | War Scenarios |
| 4.2 (3) | Aedile Hawk’s Nest 1.1 | aedile | War Scenarios |
| 4.2 (11) | Battle of Minas Tirith v.1.1 | Lostmage | War Scenarios |
To show our appreciation of people taking the effort to rate scenarios we've added a little Top 10 of the most active raters.
Top 10 Raters
| Reviewer | Scens. rated | Minimum | Maximum | Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| frankoman | 42 | 2.8 | 5.0 | 4.16 |
| Lopat | 38 | 1.8 | 4.8 | 3.45 |
| Clarinetcat | 29 | 1.6 | 4.8 | 3.49 |
| Lord cliff | 29 | 2.6 | 5.0 | 4.27 |
| Stratego | 21 | 2.8 | 4.6 | 3.73 |
| Clubthumper | 20 | 1.4 | 4.8 | 3.72 |
| Wize1 | 20 | 1.2 | 4.2 | 3.08 |
| Gilzenaarkas | 19 | 2.0 | 5.0 | 3.93 |
| HorseArcher06 | 19 | 1.6 | 5.0 | 3.67 |
| SirWhiteWolf | 18 | 3.8 | 5.0 | 4.48 |
The average rating for the rated scenarios is 3.95.
This is divided over the five categories in the following way
- Playability: 4.05
- Creativity: 3.92
- Balance: 3.54
- Map design: 3.78
- Story: 3.67
Angel Jayhawk*
*) denotes a former staff member.